Israel said to fear US moving fast toward ‘bad deal’ that won’t block Iran from nukes

Netanyahu stresses to visiting American lawmakers need for joint Israel-US dialogue on dismantling Iranian nuclear program; Trump: We’re well on our way to a deal with Tehran

By ToI Staff and AgenciesToday, 4:50 am
US President Donald Trump (right) meets with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in the Oval Office of the White House, in Washington, February 4, 2025. (AP/Evan Vucci)

US President Donald Trump (right) meets with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in the Oval Office of the White House, in Washington, February 4, 2025. (AP/Evan Vucci)

Israel is deeply concerned that the US is closing in on a “bad deal” with Iran that will not meet Jerusalem’s stated essential conditions for ensuring the regime cannot attain nuclear weapons, a report said Thursday.

Channel 12 news reported that Israel believes the negotiations ordered by President Donald Trump with Iran, led by US special envoy to the Middle East Steve Witkoff, are “very, very advanced,” and that the US is not sharing enough information with Israel on key specific issues. This, despite an ostensibly deep ongoing dialogue between Witkoff and Strategic Affairs Minister Ron Dermer.

The report, which quoted unnamed diplomatic, political and security sources, said that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, Defense Minister Israel Katz, and a senior IDF officer who cannot be named held an urgent consultation this week on the issue.

It said that during their telephone conversation on Tuesday, Netanyahu told Trump that he “does not rule out a diplomatic approach” but only on condition that the resulting deal would “leave no trace” of Iran’s nuclear program.

Trump confirmed that this is the American intention, the report said, and that the 60-day deadline he had set for a negotiated resolution remains in force.

While this exchange eased Israel’s concerns “a little,” the TV report said, the security establishment remains very concerned about where the negotiations are headed. On the one hand, the US leadership is publicly declaring that Iran will not get nuclear weapons, but in contrast, “real progress” is being made toward a nuclear deal in a way that is “deeply disturbing,” the report cited unnamed experts as saying.

US Special Envoy Steve Witkoff (left) in Paris, France, April 17, 2025. (Ludovic Marin, Pool Photo via AP); Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi in Moscow, Russia, April 18, 2025. (Tatyana Makeyeva/Pool via AP)

The report came as Netanyahu’s office said that during a meeting Thursday with a bipartisan delegation of US Congress members, the premier discussed the importance of shared discussion on dismantling Iran’s nuclear program.

The third round of US-Iran talks, mediated by Oman, is set for Saturday. A technical, expert-level meeting, at which the sides are reportedly scheduled to begin drafting a framework for an agreement, was initially set for Wednesday but later also moved to Saturday, Tehran announced on Tuesday.

US State Department policy planning director Michael Anton will be the lead representative for the Trump administration in those technical talks, his office confirmed Thursday.

Anton was a spokesman for the White House National Security Council during Trump’s first term and served in the same office during former US president George W. Bush’s administration, but he doesn’t have a background in nuclear science.

Michael Anton at the White House in Washington, February 16, 2017. (AP/Pablo Martinez Monsivais)

Witkoff will also be present for the first round of technical talks in Oman on Saturday, State Department spokesperson Tammy Bruce said during a press briefing.

Before that meeting, the International Atomic Energy Agency will be sending a team to Iran to prepare for those talks. The IAEA will likely be tasked with monitoring Iran’s nuclear program if a deal is reached.

Speaking to reporters Thursday in the Oval Office, Trump said the US was having “very serious meetings” in the ongoing nuclear talks.

“There are only two options. One option is not a good option at all,” he said, referring to a potential military option that has been threatened if Iran pursues a nuclear weapon.

But Trump indicated that might not be necessary because “we’re doing very well on an agreement with Iran… That one is well on its way.”

“We could have a very, very good decision, and a lot of lives will be saved,” Trump added.

Trump reportedly sprung the news on Netanyahu that he was initiating the talks with Iran when the prime minister was summoned to the White House on April 7. Netanyahu said in a Hebrew statement the next day that he and Trump “agree that Iran will not have nuclear weapons. This can be done by agreement, but only if the agreement is a Libya-style agreement,” whereby those responsible “go in, blow up the facilities, dismantle all the equipment, under American supervision with American execution. That is good.”

Witkoff indicated after the first round of talks that Washington would be satisfied with a cap on Iranian nuclear enrichment and would not require the dismantling of Iran’s nuclear facilities. A day later, he backtracked and said that any agreement would require the Islamic Republic to “stop and eliminate its nuclear enrichment and weaponization program.”

Wednesday, as satellite pictures emerged showing the regime fortifying buried nuclear facilities, US Secretary of State Marco Rubio said Trump was determined to prevent Iran from attaining a nuclear weapon, and would prefer to do that by negotiations as opposed to military means. However, Rubio said the US would be willing to see Tehran have a civilian nuclear program as long as it was not enriching uranium.

Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi then declared that the Islamic Republic must be able to enrich uranium. “The core issue of enrichment itself is not negotiable,” he said.

Iran’s domestically built centrifuges are displayed in an exhibition of the country’s nuclear achievements, in Tehran, Iran, February 8, 2023. (AP/Vahid Salemi)

Standard international agreements for civilian nuclear programs have the US and the international community helping governments develop nuclear power for energy and other peaceful uses, in exchange for them swearing off making their own nuclear fuel, because of the threat that the capacity could be used for weapons.

After Trump exited the nuclear deal with world powers in 2018, Iran responded by curtailing monitoring by the International Atomic Energy Agency at nuclear sites. It has pressed ahead on enriching and stockpiling uranium that is closer to weapons-grade levels and has no civilian application, the agency says.

Advertisement

The IAEA’s director, Rafael Mariano Grossi, met Thursday with representatives from China, Russia and Iran to discuss Iran’s nuclear program, Chinese state news agency Xinhua said on Friday.

The joint meeting between the IAEA representatives and the nuclear agency’s director general came after Araghchi visited Beijing this week.

The meeting had in-depth communication on the IAEA’s role in the political and diplomatic settlement process of the Iranian nuclear program, with China expressing support for Iran’s dialogue with all parties, including with the US, Xinhua said.

Content retrieved from: https://www.timesofisrael.com/israel-said-to-fear-us-moving-fast-toward-a-bad-deal-that-wont-block-iran-from-bomb/.

About The Author

Leave a Comment